Another brutal BUT respectful vocal ranking, enjoy! This video is inspired by @everglowup and her wonderful content on stage presence in kpop! During Yeji’s section I’ve used clips of a video originally by @JinLiaTV TIMESTAMPS 0:00 This is a ranking 0 :34 The rules 1:03 Bias check? 1:49 12 3:25 11 5:24 10 6:59 9 9:08 8 10:48 7 12:50 6 15:12 5 17:44 4 20:36 3 24:17 2 27:07 1 30:28 Outro brutal vocal ranking, ain’t no other fan kpop, aespa, aespa drama, itzy, itzy lia, ninging, winter, karina, itzy yeji, red velvet killing voice, nmixx, lily, haewon, sullyoon, purple kiss, newjeans, newjeans hanni, vocal analysis, ive liz, vocal range, best vocals, vocal, kpop idols who need vocal lessons, vibrato, riffs and runs, babymonster, Blackpink contract
43 Comments
ACTUALLY it is LIZ who is the youngest vocalist on this list! My bad!
She and Hanni are like a month apart though
I think Hyein has the best vocal tone in newjeans.
I feel like na goeun should be above Liz her supported range is bigger than Liz
You didn't even considerate Le Sserafim oof. And please look up the pronunciation, it makes you seem very ignorant.
I’m just going to leave this right here…Belle – Kiss Of Life
Lilly / nigning / belle / winter / haram
cho miyeon outsang
For me, aespa is the only group that i want to hear their music everyday.
For me only Hanni's voice can fix me😭✨
PLS tell me you saw that run Miyeon did live at MAMA, she is being WASTED 😭
the nmixx bias is so freakin obvious
💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩
personally feel like Hanni's ranking is lower than what she deserves
listen to her performance on leemujin service, it could change your mind
where is monday from weeekly?
why is le sserafim not here? just asking☺️!
fromis >>>>>>>>>>>
Hmm, I was with you until you ranked Liz above Winter. Liz strains way, way more than Winter. I mean you show her covering Aespa for crying out loud and she's several steps below compared to how Winter sings those lines. I think Winter has some tension because of the kinds of songs given to Aespa, they want her to be really loud and dramatic in every song. Maybe you think Liz is more relaxed because most Ive songs are easy and low, but the clips you picked here show her struggling a ton, she's even frequently off pitch. Maybe she has a lot of potential, but she honestly doesn't sound like a main vocal here. I'd put her at the same rank as Lia, lots of potential and good at some styles, but very poor execution most of the time.
Will you consider doing Taeyeon vs Wendy vs Lily vocals? based on their 2023 vocals/latest comeback.
So we can safely say that vocal wise the strongest kpop groups are:
NMIXX: Half of their members made it here.
Aespa: 3/4 of their members made it on the list.
No surprise.
Liz and Sullyoon above Winter….?
no CHAEWON OR YUNJIN??????
I don’t think there was even a question about number 1 and 2😭
Have u ever checked out Monday from weeekly?? She's an amazing singer
I am happy to see Liz rank top 5 on this list. I wish Starship would stop putting her vocals on the back burner of songs, I mean imagine another Liz-led song like Eleven??? I mean look at what happened to Liz in KITSCH?? There were a lot of places for her to have multiple lines but instead, they just shrugged their shoulders and gave her a bone and said "Yeah the fans would LOVE this" Yeah no. They have a Grade A main vocalist and don't utilize her talents unless it is for the complicated vocals. It's odd. Imagine if SM gave Wendy fewer lines in Red Velvet?? because that's what's happening here. Liz can't grow vocally if she isn't given the chance to. Clearly, she loves to sing so why can't Starship let her. I hope the first soloist from IVE is Liz. I hope she gets the Taeyeon treatment. I just hope what I am saying isn't deemed too controversial.
I am happy to see Liz rank top 5 on this list. I wish Starship would stop putting her vocals on the back burner of songs, I mean imagine another Liz-led song like Eleven??? I mean look at what happened to Liz in KITSCH?? There were a lot of places for her to have multiple lines but instead, they just shrugged their shoulders and gave her a bone and said "Yeah the fans would LOVE this" Yeah no. They have a Grade A main vocalist and don't utilize her talents unless it is for the complicated vocals. It's odd. Imagine if SM gave Wendy fewer lines in Red Velvet?? because that's what's happening here. Liz can't grow vocally if she isn't given the chance to. Clearly, she loves to sing so why can't Starship let her. I hope the first soloist from IVE is Liz. I hope she gets the Taeyeon treatment. I just hope what I am saying isn't deemed too controversial.
Sullyoon and Liz over Winter?💀
What about Yunjin in Le Sserafim?
NMIXX = <3
aw… I thought Belle would be included as well, she's an amazing vocalist, producer and song writter
Liz plays Gymnastics with her vocal chords 💕🎶💕🎶💕🎶💕🎶…
When it comes to Vocals, sometimes the vocalist is great but you don't like the sound of their voice, and it's very rare to find a good vocalist whose Voice appeals to your hearing, to me IVE Liz and Everglow Sihyeon are 2 examples of those good vocalist whose Voice I like…now I can't determine who is a good vocalist but I wouldn't like the singing that's off key like unable to match the music even if the sound of the voice appeals to my hearing (like simple speech voice)…this is why I can only rate or promote singing voices that I like…so as I said Liz and Sihyeon, I never get enough of these 2 but I don't know where they stand in the skill spectrum..
If you have to add Julie by Kiss Of Life what will the ranking be?
good ranking, it was interesting
Karina?
faltó XG, no sé si cuente realmente, ya que no es kpop
I know Lily is the 1# place, but my fav voice is Haewon. cuz she always fits every song she sings, and she really knows how to play with her voice. I'm always surprised because her voice is actually deep, but when she sings, her voice keeps changing😂. Sometimes her voice can be sweet, powerful, deep, and her dance is even more surprising😂 because we are only shown Haewon singing without knowing that her dance is very good, powerful, and also fluid but sharp too.
Lily is so good too, but haewon caught my attention so much. I love them❤
Do a part 2 for disbanded groups😢😅
Broo viendo a las ultimas de la lista es inevitable pensar que las 3 que quedan de Nmixx estraban de sobra en la lista.. eso demuestra que todas las chicas de Nmixx son increíbles ❤️❤️❤️
Where is Jini?
The best voice in New Jeans is Danielle. Her voice is so melodious. Lily needs no critique: that girl can sing!✌️
Where yunjin !!!
lily and haewon both being the best vocalist in kpop 4th gen
Highly agree with this list (I would just swap Sullyoon to #3). I honestly think NMIXX has the top 3 best vocalists of Gen 4 GG. Lily is undoubtedly the best vocalist for Gen 4. I was amazed with Haewon and Lilys cover of survivor.