I side with phoenix. But old nobility used to end all their family lines in circles.
AboveAverageJoey3 on
I agree with Phoenix, though my only concern is there such thing as spiritual incest because of the idea that reincarnation proves that the human soul exists.
Kagemaru- on
What is that anime called? Sounds familiar
VinnieBaby22 on
My thoughts on the awareness argument (Is it incest if the parties are not aware of each others’ identity?): One doesn’t need to know they are something or that they’re doing something for it to be the case.
Example: the term for stealing a fruit (most commonly, apples) from a tree that is owned by someone else is called scrumping. Even if one wasn’t aware of that fact, completing the action would be defined by the term.
If one were to meet a sibling that they had no prior knowledge of, and then engaged in sexual acts with them, then the person in question committed incest. Maybe not intentionally, but still undoubtedly.
My thoughts on the definition of incest argument (if the parties in question are born into different physical bodies with different DNA, is it still incest?): Siblings are included in the list of partners that would constitute incest.
It would not be biological incest, as the two parties in this hypothetical situation contain DNA from two sets of separate and different parents.
BUT biology is not the only thing that makes people siblings. The term “sibling” can definitively be used to describe a person with which you have the same emotional and social connection to but have no blood relation to, such as step- or half- siblings raised in proximity from birth.
Because of this, defining the sexual act between the two parties would fall into a moral and philosophical gray zone that depended entirely on the level of relationship the two parties had with each other before they were reincarnated.
In this specific hypothetical situation, the boy has obviously connected with the girl as a sibling. The brotherly instinct to protect the sister has solidified that fact, but we have no sure proof of the girl’s connection to the boy.
With all this information, I determine the act incestuous.
-not a judge, not an expert, and not that really smart in general. please take reasoning with a grain of salt
GolettO3 on
Whilst not technically incest, if either one found out about the others identity, they would probably consider it incest. This is essentially the “is it incest if 2 step siblings, who grew up together all their life, got together?”
Akikojam on
Based on this, my question is, if it was two brothers instead of brother and sister, but they are reincarnated as opposite genders and the rest of conditions still stand… would that be gay?
santas_delibird on
Yeah, see. This is why turning debates into ace attorney forms is so much better. Especially if it’s inconsequential as this.
I love how much shit the judge got from this, very fun.
hheecckk526 on
Like they said, because they were not aware of their old lives connection and biologically are different people who lead completely different lives in this new world it is not incestuous. However, once they realize who each other are then continuing to be romantic would make it pseudo incest as the siblings will now begin to stop seeing them as different people and instead back as their sibling. Biologically it’s not incest but mentally its 100% incest if they continue the relationship from there.
Basically, phoenix was correct for the first half(imo) but then by the second half godot was correct(imo)
Dynakun86 on
9 fuckin minutes? hahahaha ill save this for later
Raeldri on
People really struggle with the concept of reincarnation and having memories of a past life
get_isekaied on
I summon u/sisterfucker24
killskillgamer on
I had more fun and emotion watching this than any tv show in the past month. Holy shit this made my day.
kingGP2001 on
Damn, i wish i had those kinds of debates, would you want another voice on discord at the next one? :))
14 Comments
I side with phoenix. But old nobility used to end all their family lines in circles.
I agree with Phoenix, though my only concern is there such thing as spiritual incest because of the idea that reincarnation proves that the human soul exists.
What is that anime called? Sounds familiar
My thoughts on the awareness argument (Is it incest if the parties are not aware of each others’ identity?): One doesn’t need to know they are something or that they’re doing something for it to be the case.
Example: the term for stealing a fruit (most commonly, apples) from a tree that is owned by someone else is called scrumping. Even if one wasn’t aware of that fact, completing the action would be defined by the term.
If one were to meet a sibling that they had no prior knowledge of, and then engaged in sexual acts with them, then the person in question committed incest. Maybe not intentionally, but still undoubtedly.
My thoughts on the definition of incest argument (if the parties in question are born into different physical bodies with different DNA, is it still incest?): Siblings are included in the list of partners that would constitute incest.
It would not be biological incest, as the two parties in this hypothetical situation contain DNA from two sets of separate and different parents.
BUT biology is not the only thing that makes people siblings. The term “sibling” can definitively be used to describe a person with which you have the same emotional and social connection to but have no blood relation to, such as step- or half- siblings raised in proximity from birth.
Because of this, defining the sexual act between the two parties would fall into a moral and philosophical gray zone that depended entirely on the level of relationship the two parties had with each other before they were reincarnated.
In this specific hypothetical situation, the boy has obviously connected with the girl as a sibling. The brotherly instinct to protect the sister has solidified that fact, but we have no sure proof of the girl’s connection to the boy.
With all this information, I determine the act incestuous.
-not a judge, not an expert, and not that really smart in general. please take reasoning with a grain of salt
Whilst not technically incest, if either one found out about the others identity, they would probably consider it incest. This is essentially the “is it incest if 2 step siblings, who grew up together all their life, got together?”
Based on this, my question is, if it was two brothers instead of brother and sister, but they are reincarnated as opposite genders and the rest of conditions still stand… would that be gay?
Yeah, see. This is why turning debates into ace attorney forms is so much better. Especially if it’s inconsequential as this.
I love how much shit the judge got from this, very fun.
Like they said, because they were not aware of their old lives connection and biologically are different people who lead completely different lives in this new world it is not incestuous. However, once they realize who each other are then continuing to be romantic would make it pseudo incest as the siblings will now begin to stop seeing them as different people and instead back as their sibling. Biologically it’s not incest but mentally its 100% incest if they continue the relationship from there.
Basically, phoenix was correct for the first half(imo) but then by the second half godot was correct(imo)
9 fuckin minutes? hahahaha ill save this for later
People really struggle with the concept of reincarnation and having memories of a past life
I summon u/sisterfucker24
I had more fun and emotion watching this than any tv show in the past month. Holy shit this made my day.
Damn, i wish i had those kinds of debates, would you want another voice on discord at the next one? :))
I side with Phoenix all the way